With
so many "understanding" books coming
in at the 120 page mark, I was delighted to see
this well-fed tome bulging in the middle--apparently
healthy and filled with vitality (in other words,
Gambit Publications has come out with yet another
impressive book).
Though I'm not familiar with the
author, Rowson made an excellent impression by
providing a nice mix of instruction, explanation,
and analysis. All this, padded with his entertaining
and energetic writing style.
For the student who has always
wanted to learn the Grunfeld, the first two instructive
chapters set the tone and actually make your mouth
water at the prospect of facing 1.d4.
In chapter three, Rowson begins a trend towards
humanizing structures and pieces by naming White's
d-pawn (at times powerful and at other times a
target) "Delroy." After naming Delroy,
he then tells you how to deal with "him"
(in a rather large and very important instructive
chapter).
Actual analysis only begins in
chapter four. In general, he offers a repertoire
approach, ignoring inferior Black tries and concentrating
on what he thinks are your best choices. Here
Rowson really shines, as he's able to combine
flair, entertainment and ideas with all the most
modern theoretical flavors. Where a "normal"
author would list chapters by variation name (The
Exchange Variation, The Russian Variation, etc.),
Rowson gives us
- Random Monkeys - (chapter
five),
- The Anchor - (chapter
six),
- Drawn Endgames? - (chapter seven),
- Check! - (chapter eight),
- The Cake and the Cookie - (chapter
nine),
- Delroy's Granite Statue - (chapter
ten),
- A Pint of Carlsberg (chapter
eleven),
- The Eager Lady (chapter twelve),
- Hydra (chapter thirteen), and
- The Silent Corridor (chapter
fourteen).
In case the reader thinks that
all these chapter headings are cute but useless,
let me set the record straight! Each heading corresponds
tightly to the chapter material, and acts as a
memory tool that will make the student's work
much easier and more enjoyable.
Of course, writing a "Black
is Okay" type of book has its pitfalls. For
example, when the author runs into a line that's
hard to meet, he finds himself facing endless
hours of analytical work in an effort to present
the student with a good answer. At times, panic
will set in and little errors may find their way
into his well-meaning recommendations. For example,
let's take a look at the following line in chapter
thirteen (Hydra): 1.d4
Nf6 2.c4 g6 3.Nc3 d5 4.Bf4 Bg7 5.e3 c5 6.dxc5
Qa5 7.Rc1 (page 191)
7...dxc4 8.Bxc4
0-0! 9.Ne2. Here Rowson
says that most sources have "massively underestimated"
this variation. Much of the reason for this resides
in the fact that 9...Qxc5
10.Qb3 Nc6 11.Nb5 Qh5,
which was once considered to be all right for
Black, actually falls on its face (according to
Rowson's book) after 12.Ng3!
Qh4 13.Nc7 g5 (he tells
us that "13...e5
leads to very sharp play, but after a great deal
of analysis, I do not believe it is adequate."
This is a bit unfair to the more serious player.
Rowson really should have given us some proof.)
14.Nf5!!
and "in all lines Black is losing material
for insufficient compensation." I must admit
feeling a bit peeved that the author didn't follow
14.Nf5
up with some more analysis. Surely a class B-player
would be confused, and even a master would be
forced to do a quick double-take before grasping
the truth of the position.
There is actually a bit of
history here: first, this idea was discovered
by Mrs. Daniela Nutu Gajic of Australia. While
showing Grandmaster Ian Rogers a game she won
against Z. Veroci, Jakarta 1997 (where Black answered
13.Nc7
with 13...e5),
she pointed out the 14.Nf5!!
idea and it soon made the pages of New in Chess
Yearbook 45 (page 14).
Obviously taken aback by
this since it interferes with his normal repertoire
recommendations, Rowson dutifully tries to give
the student an alternative. This is where the
heretofore mentioned panic enters the picture.
His offering of 9...Qxc5
10.Qb3 Qh5!? just doesn't
seem right to me. For example, he says that 11.Nb5
"is now comfortably met by 11...Na6."
Really? I would prefer White after 12.0-0
Bd7 13.Rfd1 since the
a6-Knight isn't well placed and 13...Nc5
14.Qa3 leaves Black
facing various nasty threats.
He also mentions ECO's suggestion
of 10...Qa5 11.0-0
Nbd7 12.Rfd1 Nc5 13.Qb5 Qxb5 14.Nxb5 Be6 saying,
"when it gives a few lines reaching equality,
but to my mind Black is teetering somewhere not
far from the brink: 15.Be5
Bxc4 16.Rxc4 Ne6 17.f3 a6 18.Nc7!? Rac8 19.Rdc1
Nxc7 20.Bxf6! Bxf6 21.Rxc7 Rxc7 22.Rxc7,"
and White has an enduring endgame advantage. All
this is true, but Black should try 16...Ncd7
when it's not easy to prove a significant White
plus.
Of course, some analytical and
judgment errors are going to be found in any book
where an author offers original analysis, and
such efforts deserve praise since most chess "authorities"
only parrot existing theory.
Oddly, the story of this line doesn't
end here. Chess theory marches on, and any comments
on a sharp opening should be subject to change
and reevaluation at the drop of a hat. Indeed,
it's fairly normal to find that many lines in
opening books are dated and obsolete even before
the book hits the stores!
Grunfeld players will be
happy to hear that the sharp discovery of Mrs.
Gajic is no exception. In New in Chess 49 (page
10), Ulf Dewenter offers the following against
13.Nc7 g5 14.Nf5
(!!): 14...Bxf5 15.Bg3 Nd4!! 16.Qxb7 (16.exd4
Qe4+) 16...Rab8 17.Qxb8 Qe4 18.Qxa7 Qxg2 19.Rf1
Nf3+ 20.Ke2 Bg4 21.h3 Ne4.
Naturally, questions also
arise here, but I think it's now clear that any
serious study of an opening must be supplemented
with material from other sources (and kept constantly
updated!). As mentioned earlier, this is a basic
flaw of EVERY opening book.
As far as repertoire books go,
I can highly recommend this one by Rowson. The
guy worked hard, put together every relevant Black
idea that was known at the time of writing, and
showed that he can teach and write well.
It seems that another good chess
writer has been discovered, and I look forward
to new books by Rowson in the future. If you play
the Grunfeld as Black, this is virtually a must
buy. It's also well worth getting if you find
yourself facing the Grunfeld with the White pieces.
YOU
CAN FIND THIS BOOK AT

|