Let me warn you right away. Some of the events depicted
in exquisite detail during the last half
hour of AUDITION are so disturbing
for people of the squeamish sort that they
have been known to walk out the theater gagging with
disgust before the movie ends. Dear reader, I
beseech you, if you are a person of the squeamish
sort, avoid this film. On the other hand, if
you have a cast-iron stomach and are delighted
by the delicate esthetics of hideous cruelty
(a favorite combo in Japanese culture), then
AUDITION will be just the right cup
of tea for you.

Rather than spoiling the movie by giving a scene-by-scene
summary of the plot (why do so many bonehead
reviewers do this?), I will describe it
in general terms. First, the plot draws together
various elements from several different
cinematic stereotypes including the lonely
widower, the boy who becomes a man, the friend
whose good advice is ignored, the repulsive
old lecher, the crippled dancer, the psycho
killer, the black widow, and the innocent child
victim who grows up and takes terrible
revenge. A clever subplot reveals points
of similarity and contrast between the protagonist
and his son, each of whom is looking for female
companionship. And Director Miike invests
his story's presentation with elegance,
style, a sense of mystery, and a heightened
dramatic intensity by incorporating
flash forwards, flashbacks, and dream visions
at key moments in the plot.
Eihi Shiina, Ryo Ishibashi, Tetsu Sawaki, and Jun Kunimura
display their acting expertise in the
lead roles. Shiina and Ishibashi in particular
deserve accolades. They have the
talent to reveal nuances of emotion and subtle
shifts of mood whenever the camera focuses
on their faces for a closeup – complicated
shadings of character conveyed without
recourse to speech, something that can
be done well, I believe, only by a truly accomplished actor.

AUDITION is a gorgeously photographed movie, with striking
camera angles, a sensuous use
of color, and numerous shots composed
and framed as carefully as a Hokusai woodcut
of Mount Fuji. And this masterful cinematography
is complemented by equally masterful editing. Miike surprises
us again and again with sudden, unexpected
cuts from one scene to another. He also likes
to alternate slow, peaceful scenes in
which a character sits or stands in silence,
lost in thought, with rocketship
scenes featuring hyperkinetic music and
a frantic, rapid-fire sequence of quick cuts.
Two of these quick-cut scenes deserve special praise. Either
could stand by itself, one as a humorous short-short
story, the other as a poem of nightmarish delirium. The
first scene shows us 30 actresses auditioning,
one by one, for a part in a movie. The
cuts are so rapid that we only get to see each
actress do her stuff for a few seconds, but
each bit is nicely crafted to be amusing in
a different way, with a complicated accumulative
effect that's primarily comic with
strong undercurrents of pathos and satire.
The second scene comes after the
protagonist drinks drugged whiskey, blacks
out, and falls to the floor. What we see
for the next few minutes is a surreal phantasmagoria
of events that the protagonist knows have
already happened intermixed with unspeakable
possibilities. Once again, Miike's quick
cuts greatly enhance the effect created by
this sudden onslaught of imagined
horrors. Rather than building slowly, the scene
comes at us like a lunatic with a syringe.

Music defines the mood – sweetly melancholy music for
sentimental scenes, sinister music for scenes
of ominous foreshadowing, romantic music for
love scenes, and spritely music for comic
scenes. This technical aspect of AUDITION is
too obvious, too blatantly manipulative in
its attempt to direct our emotions. Perhaps
this criticism merely reveals my personal taste.
I prefer movie music that challenges or
complicates my emotional reaction to what
I'm seeing on the screen.
Equally obvious is the fashion in which every element in many
of the scenes has been carefully contrived
to convey a particular theme or symbol. This
contrivance can be seen, for example, in the
all-too-frequent use of coincidences. During
a fishing scene, the father and the son
are discussing women when the father remarks
metaphorically that in his search for
a new wife, he wants to catch a big fish. Sure
enough, a minute later his line goes taut,
his pole bends forward, and he reels in a whopper. What
a coincidence! How symbolic! In another
scene the father has a stack of thirty
resumes fanned out on his desk and
is about to look through them one by one when
he accidentally spills a few drops of coffee
on the corner of a resume that's near the bottom.
He wipes off the coffee, then pulls the resume
out of the stack and looks at the
photo on it. You guessed it. By chance this
happens to be the resume of the actress he
falls for. How coincidental!

As in Hollywood movies, everything has been too
perfectly calculated and choreographed, a strategy
that sacrifices realism for glossy
artistry. The problem is not just that the
artistry is so noticeably contrived
but also that it shows us too clearly where
the story is going. After watching
the first 48 minutes of AUDITION, we realize
with certainty what the general nature
of the outcome will be and can also guess
many of the specific details. I'd rather
be surprised. But Miike is no fool. He
knows that morbid curiosity will keep us interested
until we actually see the movie's
horrible conclusion and learn for sure
what those specific details are.
Not everything in AUDITION is so carefully
choreographed. From time to time we see a cute
little dog named Gang romping spontaneously around
in the father's home. Unfortunately,
Gang gets whacked during that half-hour
stretch at the end.
Click to see SILMAN'S REVIEW
OF AUDITION.